• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 6.84
• Location 9.35

The Old Waverly is the largest of the Edinburgh Collection's hotels, and also the most central. Boasting many cheap offers throughout the year, the hotel is a popular stopover for larger groups and families, and a good choice for those who have little time to spare and want to be right in the centre of the action! Small, uniform rooms and uninspired decoration means the hotel lacks in personality, which is a shame for a historically listed building, but with a large refurbishment in the pipeline, things can only get better.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.4
• Location 9.52

Besides the excellent location, beautiful rooms and stunning building, the best thing about The Balmoral is its team of friendly and dedicated staff, who effortlessly give the impression that anything is possible. The hotel was first opened 15 October 1902, but didn't become The Balmoral until 1991. Expect Victorian splendor and classic elegance with a modern twist - the hotel completed a £7 million refurbishment program in March 2004, and the results are still fresh. The Balmoral is home to Edinburgh's only Michelin-starred hotel restaurant, but there are three more eateries to choose from if formal dining's not your cup of tea! Relax in the spa, lunch at Hadrian's Brasserie, or enjoy a champagne tea at the stunning Bollinger Bar. If you have time after all that, pop outside and explore Edinburgh's numerous attractions, which seem to be conveniently clustered right at The Balmoral's doorstep.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.19
• Location 7.64

Visiting Edinburgh's Hotel du Vin you would never guess that the hotel is in fact the latest addition to a nation-wide family of 15 luxury boutique hotels. A chain yes, but the hotel itself feels like a one-off Scottish phenomenon, complete with a scattering of tartan, a whiskey lounge and a cosy cigar bothy to snuggle up in on a cold winter night. Modest and stylish, Hotel du Vin has plenty of reason to blow its own horn: 47 beautifully decorated rooms and suites (with bathrooms to die for) sitting on a goldmine of history in one of Edinburgh's trendiest areas, it would be futile to cover up the fact that this little gem was one of our favourites. With a large emphasis on dining and drinking, the hotel has a labyrinth of nooks and crannies, mezzanines and wine cellars to relax in. The restaurant itself is large, open plan and delightfully provincial. Popular amongst locals and foodies, and boasting a staggering wine list to navigate your way around, the restaurant is at the heart of the hotel.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.37
• Location 9.23

As should be expected from one of the world's forefront fashion designers, Hotel Missoni is an extremely stylish, light, fresh address in the heart of Edinburgh's Medieval Old Town. The glamourous Italian fashion label is renowned for its use of colour, stripes and intricately woven fabrics, and the hotel doesn't disappoint! Every aspect of the hotel screams style, with a flamboyant palette and stunning textiles throughout. Avoiding the over-employed temptation to clad everything in tartan, Missoni nevertheless sports a subtly Scottish charm (we loved the Missoni-print kilts worn by the doormen?). Incredibly confident, Missoni is quite possibly the only hotel in the world that could get away with a multi-coloured theme, silver quilted headboards, enormous circular chill pads and shaggy rugs? and still make it look cool. The hotel feels in many ways like the set for a fashion editorial, and even the brochure reads like a mood-board, stating matter-of-factly: ?Missoni. For Scotland. Bold. Forthright. Dramatic', which sums up the Missoni experience perfectly.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 6.89
• Location 7.14

Point Hotel is a great choice budget hotel on the edge of Edinburgh's Old Town. The hotel is modern, friendly and professional, and many of the rooms have fantastic views looking up to Edinburgh castle, which is less than ten minutes' walk away. Bear in mind that Point Hotel will be closed for refurbishment November 2011 ? February 2012, when the establishment will reopen as a 4 star hotel (it currently has three).

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.12
• Location 9.83

A large, classically elegant establishment sitting on a hot address, The George has had a good couple of centuries experience in the hotel industry, and it shows! Filling up five Georgian town houses, the hotel is a successful mix of original features and contemporary style. Perched at the higher end of the four-star spectrum, The George was bought by luxury hotel brand Principle Hayley a few years back, which funded a £20 million refurbishment of the property.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.12
• Location 9.83

Located on one of Edinburgh's chic Georgian streets, The Howard is a discreet hotel whose five stars are well-deserved! If modest on the outside, the small but perfectly formed boutique hotel shows its true colours on the other side of the threshold. Elegant marble columns and gold gilded mirrors stand out against a classically Scottish décor. Boasting beautiful period features, cosy common spaces and an optional personal butler service, The Howard is the only five star establishment of its type in Edinburgh.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.38
• Location 9.83

Perched on the end of a world heritage site at the heart of Edinburgh's beautiful New Town, One Royal Circus is sitting on an extremely prestigious address. Not that you'd know, there are no flags or plaques to mark the spot. Ring the doorbell to be greeted like an old friend, and enter the beautiful high-ceilinged entrance hall, where you'll be instantly blown away by the elegance of this boutique guesthouse. The property is exceptionally well-decorated, with stylish contemporary furniture sitting alongside original Georgian features. It's impossible not to feel chuffed when you're told recurrently to make yourself at home, knowing that most of us can only dream of a home half as beautiful! The modesty of this inner-city pied-à-terre makes it even more attractive. Guests are given a tour of the property on arrival, handed over a front door key, and left to their own devices. Staff mobile numbers are pinned on a clipboard in the kitchen, should you need further assistance.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.4
• Location 9.52

Besides the excellent location, beautiful rooms and stunning building, the best thing about The Balmoral is its team of friendly and dedicated staff, who effortlessly give the impression that anything is possible. The hotel was first opened 15 October 1902, but didn't become The Balmoral until 1991. Expect Victorian splendor and classic elegance with a modern twist - the hotel completed a £7 million refurbishment program in March 2004, and the results are still fresh. The Balmoral is home to Edinburgh's only Michelin-starred hotel restaurant, but there are three more eateries to choose from if formal dining's not your cup of tea! Relax in the spa, lunch at Hadrian's Brasserie, or enjoy a champagne tea at the stunning Bollinger Bar. If you have time after all that, pop outside and explore Edinburgh's numerous attractions, which seem to be conveniently clustered right at The Balmoral's doorstep.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.39
• Location 4.32

The hotel's small black brochure warns of a ?dangerously decadent' experience, but nothing prepares you for the excessively sumptuous attention applied to every detail of Prestonfield House! Driving up to the manor is like approaching the scene of a costume drama. A winding road leads you from the suburbs of Edinburgh, through the beautifully kept fields and pasture lands of the ancient owner's manor house, where the two house cows live in luxury.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.37
• Location 9.23

As should be expected from one of the world's forefront fashion designers, Hotel Missoni is an extremely stylish, light, fresh address in the heart of Edinburgh's Medieval Old Town. The glamourous Italian fashion label is renowned for its use of colour, stripes and intricately woven fabrics, and the hotel doesn't disappoint! Every aspect of the hotel screams style, with a flamboyant palette and stunning textiles throughout. Avoiding the over-employed temptation to clad everything in tartan, Missoni nevertheless sports a subtly Scottish charm (we loved the Missoni-print kilts worn by the doormen?). Incredibly confident, Missoni is quite possibly the only hotel in the world that could get away with a multi-coloured theme, silver quilted headboards, enormous circular chill pads and shaggy rugs? and still make it look cool. The hotel feels in many ways like the set for a fashion editorial, and even the brochure reads like a mood-board, stating matter-of-factly: ?Missoni. For Scotland. Bold. Forthright. Dramatic', which sums up the Missoni experience perfectly.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.34
• Location 7.59

The Caledonian Hilton, soon to be re-branded a five star Waldorf hotel, is one of Edinburgh's iconic architectural masterpieces. Ideally located on the threshold between Edinburgh's New Town and the Old Town, The Caledonian sits the base of the infamous castle, looking out over Princes Gardens. The best thing about this hotel is its spaciousness ? a luxury in a historical town, and one that can't be changed thanks to the building's listed status. An old railway hotel, The Caley (as the hotel is affectionately known in Edinburgh) pairs period features with a modern, sophisticated decor. The hotel already has a reputation for excellence, so it's no surprise that it's going after its well-earned fifth star.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.38
• Location 9.83

Perched on the end of a world heritage site at the heart of Edinburgh's beautiful New Town, One Royal Circus is sitting on an extremely prestigious address. Not that you'd know, there are no flags or plaques to mark the spot. Ring the doorbell to be greeted like an old friend, and enter the beautiful high-ceilinged entrance hall, where you'll be instantly blown away by the elegance of this boutique guesthouse. The property is exceptionally well-decorated, with stylish contemporary furniture sitting alongside original Georgian features. It's impossible not to feel chuffed when you're told recurrently to make yourself at home, knowing that most of us can only dream of a home half as beautiful! The modesty of this inner-city pied-à-terre makes it even more attractive. Guests are given a tour of the property on arrival, handed over a front door key, and left to their own devices. Staff mobile numbers are pinned on a clipboard in the kitchen, should you need further assistance.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.19
• Location 7.64

Visiting Edinburgh's Hotel du Vin you would never guess that the hotel is in fact the latest addition to a nation-wide family of 15 luxury boutique hotels. A chain yes, but the hotel itself feels like a one-off Scottish phenomenon, complete with a scattering of tartan, a whiskey lounge and a cosy cigar bothy to snuggle up in on a cold winter night. Modest and stylish, Hotel du Vin has plenty of reason to blow its own horn: 47 beautifully decorated rooms and suites (with bathrooms to die for) sitting on a goldmine of history in one of Edinburgh's trendiest areas, it would be futile to cover up the fact that this little gem was one of our favourites. With a large emphasis on dining and drinking, the hotel has a labyrinth of nooks and crannies, mezzanines and wine cellars to relax in. The restaurant itself is large, open plan and delightfully provincial. Popular amongst locals and foodies, and boasting a staggering wine list to navigate your way around, the restaurant is at the heart of the hotel.

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.19
• Location 7.6

The Rutland is a trendy boutique hotel boasting excellent views and bold décor. With only 12 rooms, the hotel has the intimate feel of a guesthouse. Guests are also significantly outnumbered by locals and foodies in the award-winning restaurant on the first floor and cocktail bar on the ground floor. A melting pot of renaissance chic with a contemporary edge, The Rutland lends itself to a younger crowd. The hotel also boasts a swanky nightclub, The One Below, which is predictably located below the hotel... guests staying at The Rutland are automatically put on the guest list, which is quite a privilege on a busy Saturday night!

• Easyopinions nc
• Value for money 7.17
• Location 7.54

Thoroughly twenty-first century, Tigerlily is trendy and animated hotel with an emphasis on good food and drink and sumptuous design. The sociable hotel suits its George Street postcode - once Edinburgh's banking quarter, and now a haven for trendy cafes, bars and boutiques. A melting pot of traditional glamour with a contemporary edge, Tigerlily markets itself at the young professional, and the successful cocktail bar and restaurant are hubs of energy, frequented by locals and guests alike. The hotel also boasts a swanky nightclub, Lulu, in the basement of the grand Georgian listed building.