• Login
Hotel Roger Smith Hotel 0 star
Easyexperts
501 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10017 New York, United States of America -
See the map
Amy Adejokun Section editor

Unlike any other hotel in the city, the Roger Smith is one of the most personable and homely properties in New York. It may not be as fashionable or 'bling' as many of the island's hotels, but guests coming here are not looking for that anyway. The real interest is the comfortable, familiar accommodation, the convenient location, friendly service, historical interiors and original artwork (more about that in 'To Know'). Perfect for all types of traveller of any age, you'll be sure to get a warm welcome and enjoy a memorable stay at this unique property.

+
  • Family
  • Well located
  • Rest
  • Charm
  • Flight
    • Hotel Roger Smith

      Roger Smith   -   © Igor Lubinetsky

    • Hotel Roger Smith

      Roger Smith   -   © Igor Lubinetsky

       
    Compare all the prices

    Price per night - Find at 1 partner(s)
    • - Cancelon - View prices
    Show more offers

    Location 8.46 /10

    Situated on Lexington Avenue between 47th and 48th Streets, The Roger Smith is almost equidistant from Central and Bryant Parks, both within walking distance. Also a short stroll away is the following: the Rockefeller Center, St. Patrick's Cathedral, MoMA, Grand Central Station, Times Square and the shops of Fifth and Madison Avenues. There are several subway stations close to the hotel whose lines will take you uptown, downtown and to Brooklyn. JFK is 15 miles away, La Guardia 7 miles and Newark 17.

    Accommodation 8.70 /10

    The Roger Smith offers four categories of room: standard, junior suite, one bedroom suite and deluxe suite. It is a little difficult to compare them as each is individually and uniquely decorated, however they do have similar amenities. The décor is very traditional and in some cases a bit of a mish mash and would be best described as something that you may well find in your grandmother's house, perhaps in the country. Much of the wallpaper and upholstery features floral or tartan motifs, while much of the furniture is antique, from the early 20th century. The basic rooms have queen beds with a skirt to match the curtains (and sometimes the chair upholstery). You'll find a writing desk and chair, cabinet concealing the fridge on top of which is the flatscreen television (those rooms with a regular television should get new flatscreens soon, bedside tables and various other storage units, lamps and 'objets' depending on the room. Always present though are books and artwork and/or photography. Other amenities include alarm clock, telephone, iron and ironing board, DVD player and coffee/tea maker. The standard rooms don't have a safe but you can leave valuables at reception. The bathrooms are a little small and have bathtubs with regular showers, hairdryer, a small basket of toiletries and make-up mirror. The junior suites have seating areas within the bedroom and enjoy corner positions within the building and so better street views. The one bedroom suites boast separate living/dining areas as well as kitchenettes and pull-out sofas, while the deluxe suites enjoy a second single bedroom (quite pokey) and iPod docking stations. These bigger rooms also have a larger collection of art and antique furniture such as series of black and white photography and large oak dining tables.

    Overview 8.70 /10

    The exhibition, as you could justifiably call this hotel, starts from the exterior with two abstract sculptures placed either side of the door, each in front of red columns with raised carvings. It continues inside into the circular lobby with a series of further sculptures and modern paintings upon the walls. The reception desk, which is straight ahead of you as you walk in, was, on our visit, under the helm of a delightfully charming young lady you was polite and courteous. The front of her desk features a series of metal works embedded in its front (which actually continue round the room) while the surface is of marble. Behind are the old fashioned key/message boxes for each of the 130 rooms and there are a couple of iMacs here too for guests' use. Around the edges of the hall are several peach coloured paisley print armchairs while a few plants breathe life into the space. There are a couple of excellent original lifts to take you to your room, with the mail shoot still there between them. The rest of the public spaces are in excellent condition and the corridors wide and well-lit. The hotel offers complimentary wifi throughout and a collection of DVDs for use in the rooms. While there is no fitness facility within the hotel, guests can buy a pass for the New York Sports Club or Manhattan Sports Club at $15 and $45 respectively. There is a car and driver available to guests for transfers.

    Food and drink 7.70 /10

    Lily's Bar and Restaurant is a popular hangout for both guests and locals and serves food throughout the day including a brunch at the weekends. The room itself is painted a warm red colour and is covered with bright, colourful, abstract canvases and murals by Mr. Knowles and also displays some more of his sculptures. The best time to visit is during the evening when not only is there more of a crowd, but a jazz group performs. The breakfast menu features eggs, waffles, pancakes, continental fare and extras such as sausage and bacon. The selection for lunch is fairly restricted with a few salads, sandwiches and three main dishes from which to choose while the dinner menu gives a few more options including crispy black bass and roasted Long Island duck breast. The bar serves a few cocktails and wines by the glass and has a few snacky dishes such as lamb meatballs and lobster fondue to enjoy while sipping away. A pre-theatre menu at $30 is offered between 5pm and 7pm, excluding Sundays.

    To know

    The hotel has been a family-run business ever since it opened in 1928. The current owner, a certain Mr. Knowles, is an artist by profession and his works, which include paintings and sculptures, are found throughout the hotel in the public spaces and in the rooms. Not only do the works make of the hotel a kind of gallery but they also help to create that homely ambiance that guests come back for time and time again.

    Equipment

    • Restaurant
    • Internet access
    • Air conditioning

    advantage

    • Art collection
    • Friendliness of staff
    • Location
    • Jazz in restaurant
    • Original/homely décor

    disadvantages

    • No wellness/fitness facilities
    • Standard rooms without safe

    Traveller Reviews

    • Overall Score nc/10
    Hotels near to New York
    • Waldorf Astoria Waldorf Astoria Waldorf Astoria
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.44
      • Location 8.5

      As a true legend, the Waldorf Astoria has spanned the XXth century without a wrinkle. Classified in the New York City register of historical monuments since 1993, the most emblematic hotel of the American metropolis always offers a luxury environment and amenities in relation to its 5* ranking

      From
      See the offer
    • San Carlos San Carlos San Carlos
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 6.97
      • Location 8.23

      Right opposite the Kimberly on East 50th Street, the San Carlos is a solid mid-range hotel very much in the New York vain with generously proportioned rooms, classic, non-offensive décor and practical features such as the kitchenette. While the rooms are certainly highly functional and indubitably comfortable with some unique touches, spectacular they are not, catering more to those looking for a reliable Midtown base for either work or play. While the hotel does have a modest fitness centre there are no wellness facilities on site although the complimentary business centre is a bonus, as is the free continental breakfast (as long as you are not looking for anything fancy).

      From
      See the offer
    • Fitzpatrick Grand Central Fitzpatrick Grand Central Fitzpatrick Grand Central
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.11
      • Location 8.21

      One of a pair of Fitzpatrick properties on Manhattan, the Grand Central is a delightful hotel with a great location close to many of the city's major attractions. For anyone feeling a little homesick or searching for a piece of Ireland in the Big Apple, this is the place to come. Spacious rooms, classic décor, an authentic Irish pub and a staff with that charm found only in Eire, we have no doubt that everyone, no matter their nationality, will feel right at home here. And if you still have any lingering doubts, then know that Bono, Liam Neeson and the Obamas have all been guests at the Fitzpatrick Grand Central!

      From
      See the offer
    • Affinia 50 Affinia 50 Affinia 50
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 6.86
      • Location 8.2

      If you're looking for a decent, modest and practical hotel from which to discover New York, then you can't go far wrong with the Affinia 50. It is not at all along the lines of many of New York's new, design-orientated, exclusive properties, but is geared towards the tourist or business person more concerned about location and efficient service. The larger rooms in the hotel are perfect for families with several children and even the basic rooms enjoy that all-too-elusive asset in the city: space.

      From
      See the offer
    • The Benjamin The Benjamin The Benjamin
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.16
      • Location 8.31

      Although coming up to its eleventh anniversary as The Benjamin, this 1927 building now has an interior to match its Art Deco origins. During this past decade no renovation has been undertaken and it is true to say that this is starting to show. However this does not take away from the quality of the product or from the service which remains top notch. Just like the other properties in the Denihan Hospitality Group (notably the Affinias), the rooms are spacious and the hotel is ideal if you're looking for a traditional, more classic style of base from which to uncover the city. Recommended for tourists (couples, friends or families) and for business travellers wanting a comfortable space in which to work.

      From
      See the offer
    • The Alex The Alex The Alex
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.27
      • Location 7.83

      A member of The Leading Hotels of the World, The Alex is a very smart hotel with great facilities which is ready to welcome every type of traveller no matter your reasons for visiting New York. It is a high quality product with an emphasis on function and top notch service on which it delivers with impressive success. It has a decent Midtown location, rooms absolutely fit for purpose (designed by David Rockwell, restaurant at Gramercy Park Hotel), a wonderful, professional staff and a great little Japanese restaurant. We recommend this property highly for both leisure and business travellers and for friends, couples and families alike. The big thumbs up!

      From
      See the offer
    • The Kimberly The Kimberly The Kimberly
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.34
      • Location 8.12

      This is one for the traditionalists. A stalwart of the New York hotel scene, the Kimberly is primarily a suite hotel, 19th century European in style, whose grandeur has made it a favourite among foreign dignitaries and businessmen in the city for long periods. The hotel mixes old and new in several ways, including with the addition in the rooms of modern amenities to the traditional (dated) décor. It has a great location, spacious rooms and a hot nightspot in the form of Niki. This really is a hotel suited to everyone, not only in terms of the accommodations it offers, but also on a price level. If you don't want to risk trying out a new trendy hotel which often compromises space or service, the Kimberly's hotel for you.

      From
      See the offer
    • Hyatt 48 Lex Hyatt 48 Lex Hyatt 48 Lex
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.27
      • Location 8.47

      If you've read some other of our New York hotel reviews then you'll be familiar with our view of chain hotels: the one huge advantage is that, wherever you are in the world, you know exactly what to expect. With Hyatt, expectations run relatively high and the newest addition to the group's New York portfolio will certainly go a long way to justifying that attitude. The hotel has some of the largest standard rooms in the city which are superbly appointed, it has a unique public lounge, sleek design and a buzzing restaurant serving good, honest fare. The property is perfect for any type of traveller and party size and has a great central Manhattan location. Very difficult to fault.

      From
      See the offer
    Top Hotels New York
    • Trump Soho Trump Soho Trump Soho
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.47
      • Location 3.0

      We were quite simply blown away by this hotel. Rare are the occasions where there is nothing to fault, but staying here was one of those - it just couldn't put a foot wrong. Generously proportioned, impressively appointed rooms are complemented by a relaxed yet top class Italian restaurant, while the spa is a sight to behold. You'll have a tough job finding a property where the service is paralleled and don't even get us started on the views! A magnificent, modern and memorable hotel, we recommend the Trump Soho to all kinds of traveller, newcomers or old hands, couples or families. A huge thumbs up.

      From
      See the offer
    • The Mark New York The Mark New York The Mark New York
      • Easyopinions 8.00
      • Value for money 7.47
      • Location 4.26

      Q. What do you get when you take $150 million and put them into the hands of one of the world's greatest architect/designers? A. The Mark. Be under no illusions, what Jacques Grange and co have conceived in the leafy surroundings of the Upper Eastside is now the yardstick against which all other hotels will now have to measure themselves. After over two years under renovation with some of the most sought after names in the creative fields working on the project, The Mark has transformed itself from a decent hotel to a hotel of superlatives. Everything is top draw from the design to the staff, from the food to the wellness centre. This all, of course, comes with the price tag that its quality demands, however rest assured that no other hotel can come close to what The Mark has to offer.

      From
      See the offer
    • Setai Fifth Avenue Setai Fifth Avenue Setai Fifth Avenue
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.47
      • Location 9.22

      We're going to stick our necks out here and say that of all the hotels we have stayed at in this city, the Setai probably takes top spot. Of course there are many different types of hotel in the city and not everyone is looking for what the Setai has to offer, but as on overall experience, it can't, in our opinion, be bettered. The rooms are not only some of the biggest in the city, but they are likely to be the best appointed in terms of amenities too. The stunning, contemporary spa is as luxurious as it is spacious and in its restaurant the hotel has one of most memorable dining experiences to be had. But what impressed us most, and where the hotel rises above it competitors, is the consistent attention to detail and impeccable service the likes of which we've never seen. Although new (November 2010 opening), this is right up there with the old masters and the best thing is that it can only get better!

      From
      See the offer
    • The Peninsula The Peninsula The Peninsula
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 8.94
      • Location 8.13

      Let's not mince our words; The Peninsula is quite simply one of the finest hotels in New York, even more so now it is the other side of a renovation. From the very first moment you enter the hotel you'll have no doubt about the quality of experience that awaits you. There is very little to pick holes at here where excellence comes as standard: the large rooms are finely furnished, the restaurants of the highest caliber, the spa one of the most beautiful and complete in the city and the service faultless. Like all top class hotels this all comes at a certain price, however if there was ever one hotel which could justify the cost it would be this one.

      From
      See the offer
    • The Carlyle The Carlyle The Carlyle
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.45
      • Location 4.32

      This mythical New York hotel has seen its fair share of changes, both within in its walls and outside, however one thing remains constant: The Carlyle is one of the swankiest, smartest, seductive hotels in the city. The very few flaws of the hotel (for example the size of some bathrooms) can be excused by its age; otherwise there are very few hotels of this genre which can claim to offer a similar experience. Not only does it offer top notch service and facilities, but its location and commanding views are also something spectacular. Throw in a rich history, fine dining and exquisite décor and you get a hotel (literally) fit for kings. If you've got the cash, don't even ask yourself the question?

      From
      See the offer
    • The Pierre The Pierre The Pierre
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.45
      • Location 6.24

      The Pierre has always been a landmark hotel in New York City?and we are glad to report that after its latest $100 million renovation following its takeover by Taj Hotels, it is still very much one of the hotels by which others must judge themselves. It is true to say that it may not have some of the facilities of some of the other top hotels (no spa, smaller rooms), but when it comes to service, style and sophistication, not to mention history, it is untouchable. With a location that would make most hotels weep with envy, fabulously appointed rooms with an Asian touch and a new, top quality restaurant, The Pierre is back on top of its game and ready to welcome once again all types of traveller, no matter their motive for visiting the city. All this comes, of course, at a price, but if you had to choose a place to spend your hard earned cash, this has got to be near the summit of your shortlist.

      From
      See the offer
    • Plaza Athénée Plaza Athénée Plaza Athénée
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.45
      • Location 3.0

      Although no longer associated with its Parisian namesake, the Plaza Athénée New York continues to offer one of the most refined hotel experiences in the city. Its style may not be as subtle as some of its competitors and thus some many find it a little overwhelming, but there is no getting away from the fact the hotel is a class act from top to bottom. It boasts capacious, well-appointed and recently renovated rooms (January 2010), a fine wellness centre, a celebrated restaurant and bar and an impeccable service from a smart, professional staff. If you're after that classic European opulence the other side of the Atlantic then the well-located Plaza Athénée is one to consider.

      From
      See the offer
    • The Chatwal The Chatwal The Chatwal
      • Easyopinions nc
      • Value for money 7.45
      • Location 9.8

      Take a step back in time (through a passage lined with suede and leather, of course) to the golden age of travel and the magnificent new Art Deco hotel The Chatwal. Opened recently in August of 2011, it has quickly become one of the places to stay in New York and to be honest, it isn't difficult to see why: a dream location in the heart of Manhattan, superbly appointed, world ?class accommodations, a luxury spa and a fine restaurant. Marrying both old world glamour and modern day luxury, this 'baby grand' hotel will appeal to those looking for good old fashioned service in a romantic setting with everything that makes this a great city within reach.

      From
      See the offer